| DAT | MOTSTÅNDARE | RESULTAT | MÅLGÖRARE | pl | |
| 2 sep | H | STOCKPORT COUNTY | 0-0 |
||
| 9 | b | Leeds City | 0-0 |
||
| 11 | H | DERBY COUNTY | 1-0 | Freeman | |
| 16 | H | WOLVERHAMPTON W | 4-0 | Woodward, Brown, Freeman 2 | |
| 23 | b | Leicester Fosse | 0-2 |
||
| 30 | H | GAINSBOROUGH TRINITY | 1-0 | Whittingham str | |
| 7 okt | b | Grimsby Town | 1-2 |
Douglas | |
| 14 | H | NOTTINGHAM FOREST | 2-0 | Whittingham, Dodd | |
| 21 | b | Burnley | 2-2 |
Bridgeman 2 | |
| 28 | b | Clapham Orient | 4-1 | Douglas 2, Whittingham, Dodd | |
| 4 nov | H | BRISTOL CITY | 2-2 |
Whittingham 2 | |
| 11 | b | Birmingham | 4-1 | Thomson, Dodd 3 | |
| 18 | H | HUDDERSFIELD TOWN | 3-1 | Whittingham str, Thomson 2 | |
| 25 | b | Blackpool | 0-1 |
||
| 2 dec | H | GLOSSOP NORTH END | 1-0 | Thomson | |
| 9 | b | Hull City | 0-1 |
||
| 16 | H | BURNLEY | 2-1 | Whittingham, Bridgeman | |
| 23 | b | Bradford Park Avenue | 1-1 |
Dodd | |
| 25 | b | Fulham | 1-0 | Whittingham | |
| 26 | H | FULHAM | 1-0 | Dodd | |
| 30 | b | Stockport County | 1-0 | Whittingham | |
| 1912 6 jan |
H | LEEDS CITY | 4-2 | Downing, Thomson, Dodd, Bridgeman | |
| 20 | b | Wolverhampton W | 1-3 |
Whittingham | |
| 27 | H | LEICESTER FOSSE | 2-1 | Ormiston, Whittingham | |
| 10 feb | H | GRIMSBY TOWN | 4-1 | Whittingham 2, Thomson, Freeman | |
| 17 | b | Nottingham Forest | 3-2 | Whittingham 3 | |
| 24 | H | BURNLEY | 0-2 |
||
| 2 mars | H | CLAPHAM ORIENT | 3-0 | Whittingham 3 | |
| 9 | b | Bristol City | 1-1 |
Whittingham | |
| 16 | H | BIRMINGHAM | 0-2 |
||
| 20 | b | Gainsborough Trinity | 2-0 | Whittingham, Hilsdon | |
| 23 | b | Huddersfield Town | 3-1 | Whittingham 2, Woodward | |
| 6 apr | b | Glossop North End | 2-1 | Taylor, Whittingham str | |
| 8 | b | Derby County | 0-2 |
||
| 13 | H | HULL CITY | 1-0 | Freeman | |
| 22 | H | BLACKPOOL | 4-1 | Taylor, Thoomson, Bridgeman 2 | |
| 25 | b | Barnsley | 2-0 | Whittingham, Freeman | |
| 27 | H | BRADFORD PARK AVENUE | 1-0 | Freeman | 2 |